Rafe returns from hell, Caleb tells Alison that Rafes back, While Olivia wishes upon the ring…
I love how Caleb closed the door. like its on, baby. LOL
Damn John from OlTL and Caleb is hott he looks a lil better to me without his beard and I LOVE the vampire fangs
What a wish you made Livvie your worst nightmare came true
@ILuvZacEfron18 this is the same night that livvie stole calebs ring, rafe went to hell, and of course caleb and ali have sex.
what epi is this