The Classic TV Site

Common Hospital: Night Shift – The Complete First Season

[wpramazon asin="B000YM6DNW"]

posted by in Soap Operas and have Comments (3)

3 Responses to “Common Hospital: Night Shift – The Complete First Season”

  1. Cafetasia says:
    28 of 32 people found the following review helpful:
    1.0 out of 5 stars
    A letdown, December 7, 2007
    This review is from: General Hospital: Night Shift – The Complete First Season (DVD)

    This was a waste of time. I went into it believing it would be about something and was left disappointed. Bob Guza (head writer) and Brian Frons (pres of ABC) basically pulled a bait and switch on fans. They said it would be about the popular couple Patrick and Robin and that this show wouldn’t carry over to the original soap, General Hospital. On NS, it didn’t seem like Patrick and Robin (Scrubs) even liked each other. And a lot of the stories did carry over, so that in fact it wasn’t an alternative universe that was promised.

    Whether you were a previous GH watcher or a new watcher all together, this series will leave you confused with its inconsistencies, bad editing, and lame writing. To be fair there were some highlights, but they didn’t outweigh the bad.

    The Bad:
    - The non-chemistry filled “relationship” between Patrick and nurse Leyla, played by an actress with the screen presence and acting ability of a paper bag.
    - The lack of screen time of the vixen you can’t help but love, Maxie Jones (played brilliantly by Kristin Storms)
    - The writing and editing.
    - The lack of relationship development between Patrick and Robin.
    - The confusing ending. Not worth it.
    - The character destruction of Patrick Drake.

    The Highlights:
    - Actresses like Minae Noji and Kent King who were given the chance to show what they were capable of.
    - New finds like the charismatic and talented Dominic Rains.
    - When they highlighted Billy Dee Williams in more than just mopping the floor.
    - The acting from Kimberly McCullough. There is a reason this woman is a two time Emmy award winner. Despite the crappy writing and the obsessive baby desires of her character, you just felt for her and cried along with her when the world was crumbling before her.
    - Other note worthy performances where Bradford Anderson and Steve Burton.

    What promised to be a riveting series, turned out to be a complete let down. If you want to see a love story, because we are all suckers for a good love story, this is definitely not the show. You want good writing and decent storytelling. Also not the show. I would only buy this DVD if by some miracle it was a different series all together. Since it’s not, save yourself the disappointment and money. Mr. Bob Guza thanks for nothing. You do not know the fans at all.

    Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 

    Was this review helpful to you? Yes

  2. Wendy C. Rigney says:
    34 of 41 people found the following review helpful:
    1.0 out of 5 stars
    Total waste of talent and money…, December 10, 2007
    Wendy C. Rigney (Troy, NY USA) –

    This review is from: General Hospital: Night Shift – The Complete First Season (DVD)

    Last spring, Brian Frons, head of ABC Daytime, was touting an upcoming prime-time spinoff of General Hospital, called General Hospital: Night Shift. He and others were all smiles, saying as how the mob-obsessed head writer, Robert Guza, Jr., did not have the “time” to tell the story of Patrick and Robin on GH, that GH: NS would do so, focusing on their romantic relationship.

    Too bad he and everyone else lied.

    Instead, what the viewers got was complete character destruction and the assassination of the very couple used in the ads to draw the suckers…er, viewers…in. We had thirteen weeks of a show used to glorify the non-existent charisma of character Student Nurse Leyla Mir – a nurse whose only redeeming characteristic was looking as if she stepped out of an ’80s beauty pageant – all while either killing pregnant women by neglect and managing to be rewarded for her screw ups, but I digress.

    The viewers who were promised focus on the “Scrubs” (Patrick/Robin) relationship instead saw Patrick stripped of any tenderness, humor, and empathy – most especially apparent with the character of Robin – and turned into a jackass of monumental proportions. It is a testament of Jason Thompson’s skill that Patrick and Robin are still root-for on GH, the main show, as had everyone seen this, I’m not so sure that would be the case. Thank God for his chemistry with Kimberly McCullough, which, naturally, made the lack of chemistry with Leyla that much more appalling. So, naturally, we had “Scrubs” break up and had the chemistry-free pairing of Patrick/Leyla dominate for about eight of the thirteen weeks. Never mind the pesky commercials promoting “Scrubs” up to the very end. Force feeding was the name of the game.

    Speaking of Kimberly McCullough, she also deserves major kudos and combat pay of her own for managing to still make Robin sympathetic in the face of Bob Guza and Company trying to make her into a baby-obsessed shrew over a patient she knew for five minutes. No doubt this was done to try and make Patrick’s choice to turn to the other woman sympathetic, but as much of everything else this regime tries, it failed. There is a reason Miss McCullough has two Daytime Emmys to her name, turning crap into gold.

    And do not get me started on the waste of talent of Billy Dee Williams, whose character’s sole mission was to mop floors while giving “sage” advice to the masses, including hitman-turned-janitor Jason Morgan.

    The sole high points of the supporting cast include Kent King, Minae Noji, and Dominic Rains. If GH were still about the hospital, they would no doubt be welcome additions on a more regular basis, instead of token extras that they sadly are. (Thus showing contracts mean squat if you’re not in the mob. Ask Kent King, one of the three who does have a contract. Surprised? Thought so.)

    However, those few good supporting actors and the talent of Mr. Thompson (who truly got the raw end of the deal here) and Miss McCullough (that is where the one star comes in; if there was a way to put none, I would have!) was wasted on a project that gave new meaning to the term, “bait and switch”. And it is a shame, as had the show delivered what it had promised – romance with Patrick/Robin and medical stories – of which there were few – this DVD may have had a chance of succeeding.

    As it is, you’re better off spending your money on a show that is actually entertaining and enjoyable and not some exercise in futility, frustration, disappointment, and pain.

    Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 

    Was this review helpful to you? Yes

  3. Filegirl "Filegirl" says:
    17 of 19 people found the following review helpful:
    1.0 out of 5 stars
    Guza’s folly, December 10, 2007
    This review is from: General Hospital: Night Shift – The Complete First Season (DVD)

    After being billed as a show case for the Patrick and Robin characters, this series completely trashed the character of Patrick, gave us the chemistry black hole that is Patrick and Leyla (an abomination that bled over to GH, unfortunately) and was generally a kick in the teeth to fans. NO WAY would I buy this. Its only due to the overall awesomeness of Jason Thompson and Kimberly McCullough that this couple was not ruined beyond the point of repair.

    Help other customers find the most helpful reviews 

    Was this review helpful to you? Yes

Place your comment

Please fill your data and comment below.
Your comment
Get Adobe Flash playerPlugin by wordpress themes